The Xiaomi Mi Note Pro and Mi Note Review
by Joshua Ho on September 11, 2015 9:00 AM ESTVideo Performance
Now that we’ve discussed still image performance, we can start to look at video performance. This is often a difficult area for a smartphone due to the extra constraints and the real-time nature of this type of workload. While it might be possible to defer saving a video until recording has finished or do so in an asynchronous manner, image processing is on a strict deadline to finish in 32ms or less if there are to be no frame drops in a video. It’s also important to maximize quality here by using advanced image processing techniques such as electronic image stabilization to eliminate hand shake and possibly HDR to improve dynamic range within the video. In the case of the Mi Note line, as far as I can tell Xiaomi is solely relying upon the SoC’s ISP for video processing so pretty much any difference between the Mi Note Pro and Mi Note would come down to Xiaomi’s tweaks and the difference in SoC ISP/ISP software stack.
In the case of 1080p30 video, the Mi Note and Mi Note Pro uses 15 Mbps H.264 baseline to encode the video, which is odd because the encoder blocks are definitely capable of H.264 high profile. The audio stream is 96 Kbps AAC, which should be sufficient for acceptable audio quality. It’s really strange that this is the case, but for whatever reason it looks like the Mi Note Pro basically doesn’t stabilize the video footage at all while the iPhone 6 has strong video stabilization and almost looks like it’s using OIS without the associated issues with mid-video OIS resets. The Mi Note is stabilized to some extent but it clearly suffers from the classic problem of OIS-stabilized video in the form of moments of stability punctuated by sharp, jerky camera movements. Compared to the iPhone 6 there are also problems with a bit of excessive blur as once again at the end of the video you can see how distant, detailed objects have fine detail blurred away. Video output here isn’t too far off from the Galaxy S6, but the OIS of the Galaxy S6 is definitely more effective and also has more detail.
Interestingly enough, neither phone supports 1080p60 video despite the presence of 4K30 support, which means 1080p60 video definitely has to be possible.
Moving on to 4K video comparisons, since the iPhone doesn’t support 4K video I used the Galaxy S6 as a comparison point. Weirdly enough it looks like 4K video actually has OIS working due to the characteristic reset behavior that we’ve seen in a number of videos recorded with OIS on. Both the Mi Note and Mi Note Pro have the same audio settings and encoder settings here. The only difference from 1080p30 is that the Mi Note Pro uses 42 Mbps encoding, while the Mi Note uses 40 Mbps encoding for video. Weirdly enough, in this case I actually think the Mi Note Pro ends up with better image quality than the Galaxy S6 as the video is sharper and generally has better detail with more realistic colors. However, the Mi Note Pro’s stabilization is clearly worse and Xiaomi needs to improve their image stabilization if they want to really beat the very best here. The Mi Note is clearly not as good as the Mi Note Pro as the colors are like the Galaxy S6’s, with less detail and dynamic range than the Mi Note Pro almost universally.
In slow motion, the Mi Note Pro and Mi Note both lack any sound recording and both roughly have 8 Mbps H.264 baseline encoding. However, it’s interesting to see that the Mi Note Pro has this encoding for 720p30 playback, while the Mi Note only has about 26 FPS. Both have roughly equivalent detail in these videos, but the Mi Note Pro has more natural processing while the Mi Note has a higher contrast setting with some odd color shifting. Compared to the iPhone 6, slow motion footage is zoomed in closer but for some reason it doesn’t feel like detail actually improves much. Interestingly, the Galaxy S6 is clearly superior at slow motion video than everything else in these comparisons, which is probably mostly attributable to the widest field of view out of all four phones in this test.
Overall, the video performance of the Mi Note and Mi Note Pro is a mixed bag but mostly good. The Mi Note clearly suffers from tuning issues that the Mi Note Pro avoids, but for whatever reason 1080p30 video on the Mi Note Pro clearly has no stabilization at all. If Xiaomi improves video stabilization, they actually wouldn’t be too far off from the iPhone 6 in video quality after some improvements to fine detail processing. The Galaxy S6 still clearly stands out here for better OIS than the Mi Note, but this is mostly of interest in low light shots rather than video as I’m increasingly convinced good EIS is much better for video than OIS. It’s interesting to also see how in 4K the Mi Note Pro is clearly better than the Galaxy S6 for detail, even if stabilization means it’s really hard to see the detail if the person behind the camera is unable to keep the phone still. The Mi Note Pro is also consistently better at accurately capturing the color and white balance of this outdoor scene, which is surprising given that the Galaxy S6 has a color spectrum sensor to help determine white balance.
Facebook
Twitter
RSS
94 Comments
View All Comments
Mike89 - Thursday, October 15, 2015 - link
Xiaomi phones are not optimized for the US. I bought the Redmi Note 2 and when I got it found it would only do 2G in the US no matter the carrier. For every model number there are numerous sub versions of the same model number for different Countries and for the most part the vendors don't tell you which one they are selling. Mine (from Gearbest) was the China version even though it was stated "worldwide". Doesn't have the right bands or the right bands activated for US use.1010101100 - Thursday, October 29, 2015 - link
Did you even research the product you wanted before getting it? Did take time to check what bands were supported for the product? Did you have knowledge that not all out of state phones might not work within the US? Lastly did you research to see what data speed your carrier provided for the product you were planning to buy? I'm using a Mi Note Pro right now and have no complaints about my data speed since I know for sure at best right now its HSPA+ on T-Mobile or ATT, currently on the GoSmart mobile prepaid network available in NYC. Like someone mentioned earlier majority of our products sold in the US is produced from China for cheap labor and production cost. The design of a certain product can be from US but was not produced in US but from another country mainly China hence the term "Made in China". Leather goods from India or Italy. Surely US is not at a point where it's just stealing credit for the manual labor? I mean Apple has already been stealing credit for where it should be given.irresistible - Thursday, July 7, 2016 - link
After reading this review I decieded to buy an Xiaomi Note Pro for 500€ including all shipping costs and taxes.Today I own an Xiaomi Note Pro for over seven months now and while using it daily, I can assure you the following :
1. Qualcomm Snapdragon 810 has different versions (check here http://www.anandtech.com/show/9388/comparing-snapd...
Xiaomi Note Pro has one of the best version (v.2.1), if not the best version. Therefore the main overheating issue does not exist. From my real-world testing, I assure you that it's not getting warm at 30 degree Celsius room temperature when doing basic tasks (messaging, calls, browsing and so on). When playing taxing games, it will get warm (not hot!) at 30 degree Celsius room temperature. When watching movies for many hours with hardware-acceleration (mandatory in my opinion) your phone will get warm (not hot!). So basically if your room-temperature is about 20 degree Celsius your phone will not even get warm. Were is the overheating issue? If you are gaming 24/7h on max brightness without hardware-acceleration, you might experience throttling. All other scenarios have 0 overheating issues. In my opinion Xiaomi Note Pro is not optimal for heavy daily gaming.
2. Camera
It's okay for most people, but nothing special. Shooting is very quick. Like SNAP (1sec) and picture is taken :). It's true that the low-light performance is not good, but which phone has good low-light performance? Oh, yea you are right, flaghship phones which STARTS at 500-700$.
3. Storage
Non-expandable storage is not always to be seen negatively. Xiaomi Note Pro is 6.9mm thick and it was released at a date were micro-SD slot was not implemented on flagship phones for various reasons. And still to-date there is only a handful phones e.g. Samsung Galaxy S7 which incorporate flagship design with an micro-SD card slot. For the vast majority of users 64GB is more than enough. And those who want more, shouldn't buy this phone.
4. Battery Life
You cannot call battery life: subpar. Why not? This phone is only 6.9mm thick (!!!) and comes with an 1440p display (!!!). And they were able to implement an 3000mah battery, which is huge. But it's also true that it's powerdraw ratio is not that good. Battery lasts about one whole day for most tasks including watching videos (hardware accelerated). You can drastically optimize your battery life with xposed modules e.g. amplifiy, greenify and so on. If you want even more battery life, you can buy Xiaomi Note (non-pro) edition. If you want to do heavy gaming over multiple hours, you shouldn't buy this phone. Games, especially not hardware-accelerated on max brightness will drain your battery fairly quickly. If the battery capacity would be about 2000mah, I would call that sub-par, not 3000mah. Do not forget that this phone is supporting Quick Charge 2.0, your charging time is not that long compared to other phones.
5. Gaming in general
If you are like me and play games on your phone occasionally on the way to work or school or whatever, your battery life will be fine. But if you are sitting down on breaks or e.g. in a park with super nice sunlight playing 3-5 hours at max. brightness your favorite JRPG, your battery won't last a whole day. If you are me, you would solve this issue by connecting an sleek powerbank from Xiaomi :)
If you have any questions, feel freeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee to ask meeeeeeeeeee.
I would like to end this write-up with the following:
Xiaomi Mi Note Pro is the best 1440p 5.7" smartphone in the world. Only Galaxy Note 5 can compete. (summer 2016)
Coffeemilotea - Saturday, October 8, 2016 - link
Hi is your phone with Android 6.0 Marshmallow or KitKat with MIUI 8? Thanks.